In today's r/MaliciousCompliance story, OP is dealing with a HOA who's trying to fine him $4000 so he used their own rules against them.
00:00 Intro
09:03 Comments
09:43 Story 2 u/bingbong_Iamwrong
15:16 Comments
15:58 Story 3 u/vikingzx
18:53 Comments
19:41 Story 4 u/cockadoodleinmyass
26:35 Comments
27:25 Outro
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
[00:00:01] [SPEAKER_01] Hey Waffle Gang, I do hope you are well. My name is Mark and today we're checking out some more Reddit Stories. And if you do love a Reddit Story, why not consider that like, subscribe, maybe that notification bell too. And let's crack on with today's first story. Much love guys. Now today we're covering stories from the malicious compliance subreddit starting with DodoHead974 who says, Florida HOA nightmare. Old certified mail for a communication. You got it.
[00:00:30] [SPEAKER_01] Posting this now because I no longer live in the house or neighborhood. But at the time I lived in a lovely cookie cutter neighborhood with an HOA. This was one of those neighborhoods where they finished like a hundred homes in the span of a few weeks and it was common to see eight or ten moving trucks on any given weekend. The neighborhood went from ghost town to filled in literally a month. In Florida, most HOAs are required to use certified mail by notifying homeowners of violations.
[00:00:58] [SPEAKER_01] My HOA took this a step further that all notifications to the board would be through certified mail. Received a violation? Response in certified mail. Requesting a hearing? Certified mail. Want the bylaws? Certified mail.
[00:01:15] [SPEAKER_01] Now this last one might strike you as odd because how would you know to request the bylaws by certified mail if you didn't have the bylaws already you might ask. Let's put a pin in that one for now because upon moving in they were kind enough to provide the CC&Rs outlining what we could and could not do. But not the bylaws that told us how to handle violations and complaints. So I moved in and everything is great.
[00:01:41] [SPEAKER_01] At first. That is about until the third month when there's a big packet taped to my door. A notice of intent to lien. The packet explains that I was delinquent on a number of violations. Many of them repetitive. On the list are things like. Not keeping the garbage cans out of sight. We kept them on the side of the house like most neighbors. Standing water in between the sides of the homes. Grading issue whilst fighting with a developer over.
[00:02:10] [SPEAKER_01] Parking one of the vehicles in the driveway but over the sidewalk line. Bushes not trimmed appropriately. Unapproved modifications to the doorway. Installing a ring doorbell camera. The list went on but totaled $4,032.12 for violations, late fees and legal fees. I immediately email requesting more information and don't get a response. I do this for a few days before threatening legal action in an admittedly hostile emails.
[00:02:40] [SPEAKER_01] To which I finally get a response indicating that all communications regarding violations will only be addressed via communication methods approved in the bylaws. I request a copy of the bylaws. All requests for the bylaws must be submitted via approved communication methods as per the bylaws. At this point I'm about to go postal. But if Edmund Dante could wait 14 years for revenge, I could take a breath and figure this out.
[00:03:06] [SPEAKER_01] The notice gave me 45 days and it had only been a couple of days. I had time to figure this out. Little known fact about developers and HOAs in Florida. The developer is the one that drafts the initial CCNR, bylaws and legal documents, then hands it off to the board. My developer, whose name starts with D and ends with a word that sounds like schmorton, was already on my shit list for a number of issues. Including the improper grading.
[00:03:33] [SPEAKER_01] When I emailed my contacts requesting a copy of the bylaws. I don't think they wanted to add to the growing list of shit I was vehemently emailing them about already and had a copy within minutes. That's when I found the certified mail language. Now, the wheels were turning. Because as stated, all communication was to be by certified mail. Each violation was to be filed separately and delivered by certified mail. Each notice of failure to cure and the late fee, certified mail. Everything.
[00:04:03] [SPEAKER_01] At 8 unique violations plus repeat violations over a period of 9 weeks. At a minimum, I should have received like 22 notices via certified mail at around $7 a pop. Cue malicious compliance. My revenge. I mean, malicious compliance was two-pronged. My morality has developed to a fashion that if you want to wrongfully take from me, I'm willing to spend just as much as you want to fight you. They wanted 4k from me.
[00:04:32] [SPEAKER_01] I was willing to spend a good amount of that just to fuck with them. I took off two days from work and prepared a little game of fuck around and find out. So step one was to draft a single page. No personal details, but explaining my situation and warning any neighbors going through something similar. What the bylaws indicated and that all homeowners should immediately request a copy of the bylaws via certified mail.
[00:04:55] [SPEAKER_01] I provided the board address, the language to include, which stipulated that the response from the board, even if it was a copy of the bylaws, was to be by certified mail. Meaning a printed copy of the bylaws, which was 29 pages. I also encouraged anyone fighting infractions or having received a notice of intent to lean what to do. I printed about 150 copies because that's how many houses were in the neighborhood. Roped in a few close neighbors and we stuck a notice on about every door.
[00:05:24] [SPEAKER_01] Step two was to fight each violation individually. I drafted a template language indicating that I was refuting each violation. Some more boilerplate language on why it was refuting it and the coup de grace, a final addendum formally requesting copy of receipt of delivery for each notice having been delivered by certified mail. As per the bylaws.
[00:05:46] [SPEAKER_01] I customized each one specific to the violation and copied in any specific language from the CCNR that proved I was not in violation and sent 23 certified letters. 22 for violations and an extra one that was notice of contest for the lien. Here's another little tidbit about Florida law. HOAs operate under something called rebuttable presumption. Meaning any request for official records had to be responded to within 10 days.
[00:06:14] [SPEAKER_01] I sent the letters on a Thursday and each letter included a request for official records. A copy of the record of delivery. They had two weeks. About a week and a half later I got a very strongly worded email basically saying all the violations were valid. And that I had another 25 days to comply or they would pursue the lien. I responded tersely. All communications regarding violations must be done in approved communication methods as per article 9. Communication methods as per the bylaws.
[00:06:43] [SPEAKER_01] They had a few days to draft a response and include the records I requested and mail them to me. Certified and individually. As per the bylaws. They never did. So I sent 23 more follow ups indicating they had violated the Florida Homeowners Association Act. Breach of the bylaws. And intended to pursue legal action if they did not cease and desist. I wish I could tell you I know what happened to them. During that time frame or what it was like for them. But we heard from a man married to one of the board members.
[00:07:12] [SPEAKER_01] That something like 100 of the homes requested a copy of the bylaws via certified mail. On top of the fact that they had active liens on several homes for violations. As well as 20 more homes that had been issued a notice of intent to lien. Everyone was now fighting them. Via certified fucking mail. In the end the HOA had a change of members that resulted from the legal fees and expenses incurred by having to respond to each violation via certified mail drying up the reserve.
[00:07:40] [SPEAKER_01] Turns out the board hadn't sent a single notice of violation via certified mail. And in most cases had never notified the homeowners at all. And assumed the threat of a lien would just get them to pay whatever fines were there. Why were they doing this you might ask? Simple. There was an undeveloped lot of land on the front of the neighborhood facing a main road. In front of the homes of the first people to move into the neighborhood coincidentally. Where most of the board lived.
[00:08:06] [SPEAKER_01] The developer had held on to the plot and was intending to sell it to a commercial developer. But had offered to sell it to the neighborhood at a premium. These scumbags didn't want a gas station going up in front of their homes. And were racking up violation fees from their fucking neighbors to afford the purchase through the HOA. The lien on my home never materialized. And while I never admitted it was me. Word must have gotten around because within two weeks the developer who had been dragging their feet for months on my complaints did everything.
[00:08:36] [SPEAKER_01] My entire house was regraded on both sides with French drained pudding for added measure. The sides were completely resodded and everything else taken care of. I only stayed there for like eight months total before an offer came in. That made me give the finger to short term capital gains and peace out. All in all I sent 46 certified letters. I think I spent like $350 and two days of PTO. Best money I ever fucking spent.
[00:09:03] [SPEAKER_01] I feel I always have to say this on the back of HOA stories. And you know we always cover the worst of them. So I'm not saying every HOA is the same. But sometimes they really are their own worst enemies. Imagine creating this absurd certified male only rules. To try and intimidate homeowners. Only for one guy with free time. Spite. And a printer. To completely turn the system back on them. Absolutely fair play to him. Loved the fact that he got all the neighbors involved at the same time.
[00:09:33] [SPEAKER_01] But what do you guys make of this situation? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments below. And let's move on to another story. Now our next story comes from Bing Bong. I am wrong. And says if a single radio's battery dies. Shut it all down. This happened over five years ago. And it still ticks me off whenever I think about it. Also sorry about how long this is. Lol. I was 17 working at a big theme park.
[00:10:03] [SPEAKER_01] And had been working there for the better part of a year. And I quickly picked things up. And was usually regarded as a responsible one on the team. But then it was just a bunch of us teens working a ride. We had a college student intern lead. Who was not good at leading. Or training new hires. We call him M. At my main ride it required three people minimum to operate. One person in the control booth. One at the entrance gate. And one at the exit. However we could have four or five.
[00:10:30] [SPEAKER_01] If we were incredibly busy to help deal with the line. The people in the booth and at the entrance. Could not see the person at the exit directly. So we used radios. The control booth also had a camera on the exit gate. From day one on the job. We were taught hand signals in case the radio dies. Or a quick communication. These signals were universal across the entire park. That summer three freshly certified kids. We had to take tests to prove we paid attention to training. Started the ride with someone locked inside the fence.
[00:11:01] [SPEAKER_01] AKA not in a seat. Twice it was another employee. Once it was a guest. Which was a huge deal. The thing with those incidents was that. Those in the control booth didn't notice their mistake. Until the others screamed at them to hit the E stop. Those new hires were either retrained. Or moved to a simpler ride. About one incredibly busy day. There were five of us running things. Me. M. And three others. M had been called over to another ride.
[00:11:30] [SPEAKER_01] Which normally wasn't an issue. About an hour later. Someone was scheduled to go home. And M hadn't come back yet. I called the other ride and asked them to send him back. We could have run things with the three of us. But it was super busy. And we really needed a fourth. A few minutes later. Someone. Not our lead. Was sent over to take over. Weird. But no big deal. Another hour or so went by. Someone else needed to go home. I called again. Asking for M. Also.
[00:11:59] [SPEAKER_01] All the radio's batteries were dead. Or dying. Things had slowed down. So. I being the spare fourth person. Took the radios to the office. To get fresh batteries. This took less than 10 minutes. And in that time. The guys had switched to hand signals. As we were trained. When I came back. Our lead had once again. Sent over someone else. To take his spot. At this point. I realized that M. Was probably just shooting the shit. In the nice air conditioned booth. At the other ride. Now. The guy got sent over to us. Was normally at a roller coaster.
[00:12:28] [SPEAKER_01] And hadn't been on this ride. I turned around. And the ride was stopped. Maybe three feet off the ground. With our entrance guy. Locked in the fence. The guy at the controls. Saw what he did. And hit the E stop. Something that the other screw ups. That summer. Did not think to do. We had to call up a management. And wouldn't you know. M came running over. This time. The highest of the higher ups.
[00:12:57] [SPEAKER_01] Came over as well. They pulled each of us aside. And interrogated us. Which was odd. Then walked away. And talked for like half an hour. Then they fired the guy. At the controls on the spot. And came up with BS reasons. To get the rest of us. Removed from running rides. They absolutely were only doing that. To make an example of us. I tried to rip into M. For shirking his duties. But as an anxiety ridden kid. It didn't hit very hard. I was mainly pissed off. That they fired the poor guy. Who never should have been there. In the first place.
[00:13:28] [SPEAKER_01] Remember I took the already dead radios earlier. They tried to say I had. Removed communication. From the ride area. Which prevented them. From letting controls know. They were outside the gate. They were basically trying to pin. The whole thing on me. Total bull. Because this happened. After I brought them back. Assume M threw me under the bus. For being in charge. While he wasn't there. Also. We had hand signals. I tried explaining that to them. But they didn't give a shit. I refused to sign the paperwork.
[00:13:57] [SPEAKER_01] Which would be admitting fault. So this fight was stretched over. Multiple days. Plus I was leaving for college. In like two weeks. And didn't want to spend my last days of summer. Cleaning bathrooms. They gave us a new rule. If a single radio was dying. We had to call a manager. To fetch us a new battery. Even if we had people spared. To go grab one instead. If a radio died. We had to close the ride. Managers. Managers roamed around the whole area. And were responsible for so much. So if you called them. And it wasn't urgent. It could take a long time.
[00:14:27] [SPEAKER_01] For them to show up. The next day. My radio was dying. I called the manager. Half hour goes by. I call again. My radio died. I shut down the ride. The people in the over an hour line. Got pissed. I explained to people. That we had to close. Because of the radios. Naturally. They got even more pissed. Because of how stupid that was. Manager shows up minutes later. I took the battery from him. With a smile on my face. And he left without saying a word. After many complaints. Management was magically fine.
[00:14:56] [SPEAKER_01] With us using hand signals again. I never signed that paperwork. I left for college. And funny enough. Em also went to the same college. I ran into him once. And he just kind of nodded at me. I gave him a dirty look. And I never saw him again. The next summer. I was rehired by the park. As a lead. And actually did my damn job. This story is so infuriating. In some ways. Because the actual problem. Was obvious from the start. A lazy lead. Abandoning his ride. And management scrambling. To protect themselves afterwards.
[00:15:26] [SPEAKER_01] And then trying to scapegoat. What? A 17 year old. For changing dead radio batteries. Exactly like they've been trained to do. And then. What? The management solution. Was somehow even dumber in this. If one radio dies. Shut the whole ride down. The obvious thing actually happened. And cue like the angry guests. Hour long lines freezing. And managers suddenly rediscovering. That hand signals. Had worked perfectly fine all along. Absolute morons. But in the end. Good on OP for standing up for themselves. But what do you guys make of this one?
[00:15:55] [SPEAKER_01] Let us know your thoughts. And let's have another story. From Viking ZX. Who says landlord maliciously. Compliance themselves. This happened a few years ago. In my last apartment. My roommate and I were living in a basement place. With upstairs neighbors. And the owner decided he wanted to sell. The upstairs neighbors ended up buying it. And became our new landlords. And they were awful at it. I could fill a whole post with the amount of stuff. They tried to get away with. But we're here to talk about one particular instance.
[00:16:24] [SPEAKER_01] But suffice to say. They had no idea that landlords had. Responsibilities. And simply saw us as tenants. As a source of income. That should be ever growing. Hence our rent suddenly spiking. And why we left. But there was one time. They maliciously complianced themselves. See. They had a habit of trying to push stuff on us. That was blatantly illegal. Their first contract for example. Said among other things. That they had the right to enter the apartment. At any time they wanted.
[00:16:53] [SPEAKER_01] And could go through our stuff. If they wished. Because we were living on their property. I pointed out that this was highly illegal. And they grew very upset. Saying. Well. We'll see about that. This clause later suddenly became the real one. Before we signed. One day however. Our loan fire alarm stopped working. As dutiful tenants. We reached out and said. Hey. The fire alarm stopped working. Their response was a predictable sort of. So what?
[00:17:22] [SPEAKER_01] We need to have a working fire alarm. We replied. And it's the landlord's duty to provide. Working fire alarms. They replied. No it's not. You want one. You get it. We said. The law says otherwise. And here's where they maliciously complianced themselves. Possibly because. They were getting tired of being corrected. They got snooty with this one. They got a very sarcastic response. Oh. It does. Does it? Well. We'll just see what the fire marshal has to say about that.
[00:17:51] [SPEAKER_01] Me and my roommate upon receiving this message. Burst out laughing. But. They were serious. They thought they were going to contact the fire marshal. He was going to side with them. And that they would come down on us hard. I don't know what their expressions were when we said. Okay. Yeah. Do that. However. The next morning. There's frantic knocking at our door. There's the landlord and his family. Looking very concerned with a bag of brand new fire alarms. One for each room. If I recall correctly. Even two spares.
[00:18:21] [SPEAKER_01] He begs to be let in outside of the 24 hour notice. And says it's an emergency. He has to put these alarms up right now. Try not to laugh. We let him in. And they hurriedly put one in every single room. Apologizing profusely for delay. And telling us. If you need anything. Don't hesitate to ask. I don't know how that meeting with the fire marshal went. Or if they got him. Or someone else at their office. But their attitude painted a pretty clear picture of the ultimate result. They complied maliciously.
[00:18:51] [SPEAKER_01] Thinking they'd called our bluff. The top commenter on this one said. Yeah. The fire marshal does not fuck around. When he gives you a 24 hour to remedy a problem. He's being very generous. And your consequences can be pretty extreme for missing that deadline. I just don't get the logic from the landlords in this. Because they genuinely seem to think the fire marshal. The fire marshal was going to go. Actually tenants don't need working smoke alarms. Carry on. Like what world are these people actually living in?
[00:19:18] [SPEAKER_01] And it would have been great to be like a fly on the wall in that situation. During the phone call. When he went from like smug confidence to immediate panic. The second they realized. Oh wait. This isn't optional. And we're going to get absolutely wrecked for this. But what do you guys make of this situation? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments below. And let's move on to another story from Cockadoodle in my ass. Great name. It says. You want to fix our working hours?
[00:19:46] [SPEAKER_01] Our contracts have something to say about that. Early last year. We had a new manager take over the department. He previously headed another IT department in Germany. But moved to Switzerland to take the role in hours. Our team is spread over Switzerland, Spain and Mexico. The second line in Spain and Mexico. And third line in Switzerland and Spain. It was a few months before he started making changes that were mostly small. We had to record how much time we spent on tickets.
[00:20:15] [SPEAKER_01] Provide weekly updates on our changes and projects. And our monthly department meeting became fortnightly. It meant a bit more bureaucracy here and there. But it was mostly fine. Nothing excessive. About six months in. He made a change that none of us really liked. While Switzerland and Spain are both in the same time zone. In reality our times don't really line up. Employees in Switzerland will start at any time between 7 and 8.30am.
[00:20:42] [SPEAKER_01] While Spain can start later than 9am. Lunch in Switzerland is often from 11.30 to 12.30. While Spain will wait until 1 o'clock or later. Home time in Switzerland ranges from 3.30 to 5.30. While the team in Spain will often be online until 6 o'clock. This means that meetings between the third line teams usually take place between 9 to 11.30am. And 2 to 4pm. I.e. about 4 and a half hours a day.
[00:21:12] [SPEAKER_01] Outside of those times you risk people not having started yet. Having already gone home or being out for lunch. This is what our new manager didn't like. While he couldn't really do much about lunch times. He saw the opportunity to align our start and end times. After reviewing people's calendars. He determined that enforcing an 8am to 5pm working day. Would cause the least amount of disruption to our schedules.
[00:21:37] [SPEAKER_01] This would increase the number of hours where all were available by 2 per day or 10 per week. When he told us about the change. None of us were happy. Even those that wouldn't be impacted. Because it already aligned with their usual start and finish times. Were annoyed on behalf of those who would be impacted. When we asked why the change was being made. We were simply told it was about us all being online together more. Some people complained that it would impact out of work commitments.
[00:22:05] [SPEAKER_01] And we were told he would make allowances. But only temporarily. One guy said that he only takes a 30 minute lunch break. So this would mean he goes over his weekly hours. The manager said he would look into that. Then an older member of the team asked if he had run it by HR. The manager said no. This isn't something he needs to run by HR. The same guy then asked if we would have to start recording our hours. The manager said no. This has nothing to do with recording hours. Turns out the manager made a mistake here.
[00:22:34] [SPEAKER_01] You see in Switzerland by law. Employees need to record their working hours. And employees need to retain records to ensure compliance with labor laws. There are however a few exceptions. Smaller companies can simply record the number of hours worked each day. Meanwhile senior employees can be exempted from logging their hours. If they meet a certain salary threshold. And their role allows for autonomy in the hours worked. All the engineers on the team based in Switzerland had to sign this waiver.
[00:23:04] [SPEAKER_01] It wasn't uncommon for us to work 11 hours on one day. And then 5 hours on the next. It wasn't uncommon for us to work 30 hours in one week. And 50 hours the next. We never recorded these hours. We never explicitly told our team leaders or manager. It was simply understood that some days or weeks would be busy. And as we managed our own time. We'd make up for it later. We were trusted to manage our own time. And if we didn't sign the waiver to exclude us from logging our hours.
[00:23:33] [SPEAKER_01] It would create a mess for overtime. Time in lieu etc. But one of the conditions for signing this waiver was that. We were free to determine the majority of our working hours. Which courts had clarified was defined as 50%. If we are contracted to work 40 hours a week. Then our employer can fix 20 of those hours. And we can choose when to take the other 20. The manager had now fixed 100% of our hours. We were no longer eligible for the exception granted to us.
[00:24:02] [SPEAKER_01] For us we could continue working the dictated hours. And legally we would be fine. But if someone reported our employer to the government. The company could be fined and potentially be forced to lock all employees working hours. Or lose the ability to file working time waivers. I.e. engineers couldn't work out of hours to perform maintenance and updates. The impact to the company could be huge. So the guy that asked the question went straight to HR. And informed them of the manager's new policy.
[00:24:30] [SPEAKER_01] HR recognizing the legal risk that such policy could create for the company. Went straight to the manager's director. The policy was put on hold later that day. On the Friday of the same week. Another meeting was held. The manager apologized for not familiarizing himself with Swiss labor laws before implementing the policy. And instead decided to implement a new one. Which would be legally compliant. Spain would continue with the 8am to 5pm working hours.
[00:24:57] [SPEAKER_01] To Switzerland 50% of our working hours would be fixed. 8am to 10. And 3pm to 5pm. In short. The first and last two hours of the day were fixed. And we'd have to fill in the rest with our free hours. It was dubious at best. I looked at my calendar for Monday. And see I have a meeting at 11. And another one at 3pm. So I quickly ping a message to the two people on the 11 meeting. Then Monday comes around.
[00:25:25] [SPEAKER_01] At 6am I log in. And see the other two members of the team I'd spoken to on Friday. Are logged in from home. I drop them a message to say hi. Our plans are to work until 10. And then log off until 11. When we have a meeting together with some of the team in Spain. Take lunch from 11.30 to 1.30pm. Then finish at 5pm. Two people arrive in the office at 7am. Having planned to take a two hour lunch break in the city. The rest of the team based in Switzerland.
[00:25:55] [SPEAKER_01] Another four people. Logged in at 8am. And quickly hear what the other half of the team were doing. One was working from home. So wanted to be done as soon as possible. And one had an appointment at 5.30pm. So had to stick to the manager's implied schedule. But the other two that were in the office. Had free time that evening. At 11.30pm. They left the office. Returning just before 3pm. Having spent the afternoon. On a boat sailing around Lake Zurich. At 5pm. They both left the office.
[00:26:25] [SPEAKER_01] And clocked up the rest of their hours working from home. On Tuesday. The fixed hours for the teams in both Switzerland and Spain. Were scrapped. The manager left the department. A few months later. So this manager really sort of walked into Switzerland. Thinking I'll optimize these engineers. Without first checking. A tiny detail of a Swiss labor law. And the best part is. That the team didn't even need to like rebel. Dramatically in this. They just followed his new flexible schedule. Exactly as written.
[00:26:54] [SPEAKER_01] And immediately exposed how stupid it was. You know half the team are logging at 6am. Taking yacht tier lunch breaks on Lake Zurich. And clocking back in from home later. Just perfect. Also love how the manager went from. Like at the beginning. I don't need HR. To apologizing within like 24 hours. Because the older employee who asked the right questions. Absolutely knew that disaster was coming from a mile away. But what do you guys make of this situation?
[00:27:22] [SPEAKER_01] Let us know your thoughts down in the comments below. And just a huge thank you for being here today. Getting involved in the stories. Your love. Your support. Your time. It always means the absolute world to me. So thank you so so much for being here. Truly it's absolutely amazing. And hopefully I'm going to see you in the next one. Take care. And much love.
[00:27:52] [SPEAKER_00] Watch my face. I can smell the smoke from the bacon.
[00:28:00] Yum, yum, yum.

